• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Gelato by maya: Premier Gelato Experience in Atlantic Beach, NY

Gelato by Maya in Atlantic Beach is a charming destination for authentic gelato lovers. With a carefully curated selection of rich, creamy flavors like cotton candy and s’mores mix, it offers a refreshing treat before or after a beach day. The shop is notably clean and welcoming, staffed by friendly servers who make the experience enjoyable. While parking can be tricky for non-residents, the fair prices and quality of gelato more than make up for it. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, Gelato by Maya stands out as a must-visit spot that balances simplicity with delicious, satisfying flavors.

Gelato by maya at a glance

  • Address 2041 Park St, Atlantic Beach, NY 11509, United States
  • Phone +1 347-977-9605
  • Restaurant type Ice cream shop , Coffee shop .

Photos & Gallery

Gelato by maya: Reviews & Ratings

Cal Nathan
5

Went to check out this new gelato spot in AB. Was pleasantly surprised. Fantastic selection of delicious flavors and pleasant happy servers and a brand new clean shop. Definitely recommend checking it out. Fair prices and delicious offerings! Highly recommend!

Menucha Zamler
5

Love the gelato here! Staff is super friendly and provide great service! An absolute must visit in Atlantic Beach!

Andrew Izzo
4

My in laws told us about this spot when you drive over the Atlantic Beach Bridge. Not sure about the parking situation. Still learning where you can and can’t park if you aren’t a resident. The cotton candy and s’mores mix was good. Little pricey but understandable because summer at the beach. The girl helping us could possibly work on her customer service skills.

Dino Rodriguez
4

Nice flavors, small, simple but sufficient selection of gelato. Minimal outdoor seating. Very nice location for a before, and after, visit to the beach.

Manny Cohen
5

Amazing gelato spot. A must visit for Atlantic beach visitors. Nice, very clean and great service

Location

  • Gelato by maya
    Gelato by maya
    2041 Park St, Atlantic Beach, NY 11509, United States Hotline: +1 347-977-9605

Gelato by maya, nestled in the heart of Atlantic Beach at 2041 Park St, stands out as a bright jewel among ice cream shops. This cozy spot offers a carefully curated selection of gelato flavors that capture both classic and playful tastes. Each scoop feels fresh and creamy, inviting you to linger a little longer after a day by the sea.

The shop’s clean, modern ambiance complements its friendly and attentive staff, enhancing the overall experience. Customers frequently praise the warm service and the inviting environment, making it much more than just a quick stop for a sweet treat. From favorites like cotton candy and s’mores mixes to other artisan flavors, every offering is crafted to satisfy both the casual visitor and the discerning palate.

While parking can be a slight challenge for non-residents, the location’s charm more than compensates—perfect for a refreshing pause before or after a stroll along the beach. Reasonably priced given the quality and atmosphere, Gelato by maya is a destination worth discovering. Whether you're a local or a visitor, this gelato shop promises a memorable taste of Atlantic Beach’s sweet side.

Business Information

  • Payments
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards